To borrow a phrase from Claude Rains in Casablanca, I was shocked shocked! to find that non-stop lying was going on in the MAGA game room at CNN.
Just as I (and many other rational observers) had warned in advance, CNN’s decision to gift a free hour to a pathological cult leader – to a criminal defendant, and, now, a convicted sexual abuser – did indeed fulfill our worst expectations. I said last week that allowing Trump free rein to riff his “unhinged digressions and anti-fact fulminations” would result in “a crime against sanity and democracy.” I stand by every word.
As anyone who isn’t naive surely knew would happen, Trump suckered CNN right into his sewer. Actually, it was worse than that. CNN, anxious to get maximum ratings mileage from its MAGA informercial, attached a sewer pipe to his mouth and pumped his demagogic diarrhea directly into our homes.
How else could it have gone, given the network’s decision to pack the “town hall” audience with “star”-struck Trumpers who clapped and giggled at every lie and slur? He’s their favorite TV character; they’re hard-wired to his idiotic id. They know his shtick to a T and hooted their appreciation (“YOW!”) whenever he recited the rot that he posts on social media.
With CNN’s blessing, he pounded out his Greatest Hits. No wonder they responded with such gusto! Like when he defamed E. Jean Carroll (again) by calling her “wacko.” (Yes, they laughed at a victim of sexual assault.) Like when he dismissed Carroll’s case as “hanky panky.” Like when he said, over and over, that the 2020 election was stolen. Like when he said he wants to pardon “a large portion” of the jailed Jan. 6 traitors. Like when he said that his two impeachments were a con job ginned up by “crazy Nancy Pelosi.” Like when he critiqued the Access Hollywood tape by insisting (despite his words on tape) that he hadn’t talked about grabbing women per se, that he grabbed only when “women let you.” Like when he condemned one of host Kaitlin Collins’ rebuttals by calling her “nasty.”
At all points during the endless and inevitable clusterfuck, Collins tried her best to inject some factual reality by talking just as fast as her grifting guest, but as anyone with a shred of awareness has long known, there’s no way to stand in front of his blitzkrieg without being flattened. And I’m not going to waste my time fact-checking all his lies, because I have a life and so have you.
(OK, just two: He said the ’20 election was rigged in part because “if you look what happened in Philadelphia…” Among the 60 court cases that he lost in the ’20 aftermath, judges found no such fraud in Philadelphia. Also on the show, he lied that abortion rights supporters want to kill babies in the ninth month of pregnancy – and even “after the baby was born.” Um, he got that wrong. The truth is that he and his MAGA fans want those babies to have the opportunity to be killed a few years later – as children, in schools and in malls, by Second Amendment freaks.)
Ruth Ben-Ghiat, a respected scholar of fascism, saw last night what so many of us knew would happen. She tweeted: “This is a propaganda spectacle designed to reinforce the leader cult – thus the relief and enjoyment of the audience at hearing favorite slogans and untruths…The more approval authoritarians get, the more they feel emboldened to be even more lawless. This is why this ‘town hall’ was so dangerous.”
Trump was certainly emboldened by the audience questions, which were more vapid and open-ended than any of us could’ve predicted. A succession of Trump ’20 voters and delegates posed brain-twisters like…What do you think about the “current debt situation?” and What would you do “to make things more affordable?” (His answer: drill for more oil.) And this was my favorite semi-question: “I’m worried that government will act to suppress gun rights.” (Trump’s answer, ignoring the civilian death toll of recent weeks, was that he’s the greatest Second Amendment champ in human history.)
Granted, the sick spectacle reminded those of us who love democracy what we’re up against on the road to ’24. Trump and duh Republican base hide in plain sight, making it abundantly clear what they’re willing to say and do to seize power. Maybe that will help galvanize enough Americans to stop them once again. David Jolly, a former Republican congressman, seems to think so; he tweeted last night that “Trump is not picking up a single new general election voter. And every voter who came out in 18, ’20 & ’22 to stop him now remembers why.” Maybe so.
But that does not excuse CNN for debasing itself last night. To do responsible journalism, it’s really not rocket science. If you feel compelled to put this guy on the air, you do it in a studio with two sharp questioners. At minimum, that format ups the odds of holding him at least somewhat accountable for his pathological lies. What you don’t do is precisely what the network did. The lesson is simple:
Never fellate a fascist.